Chapter preview · Arc III — Validate before you commit
Chapter 11 — Beyond Mockups
What to Build Before You Build
Hardware teams have four distinct validation instruments — proof of concept, mockup, prototype, and pre-production unit — each designed to answer a different question. The discipline is matching the right instrument to the right question, and understanding what each one can and cannot prove.
The Million-Euro Mockup
In a warehouse outside Zaragoza, a team of engineers at CAF (Construcciones y Auxiliar de Ferrocarriles) — a Spanish manufacturer of railway vehicles, equipment, and buses — spent nearly a year building a single railroad car. That car would never carry a passenger. The million-euro mockup was created for a single purpose: to let a focus group of Dutch commuters sit in the seats, plug into the sockets, and judge the sightlines before Nederlandse Spoorwegen committed billions to a fleet order.
A million euros may sound like a lot for a dummy. It is — but it's a rounding error on a multi-billion-euro fleet order. More importantly, what that mockup delivers — direct evidence of user acceptance — is something no brochure, specification document, or rendering can deliver reliably.
Want to read the rest?
Chapter 11 goes on to map the four validation instruments — when each one applies, what it costs, and what it can't prove. Join the early access list to get the full chapter and the rest of the book.
Join the Early Access List